Still cyclingThis site is under construction, just like the tank. Expect a little algae, some ammonia spikes, and new stuff showing up every week.

This is a placeholder tank. The real one has more algae and less self-respect.

Viewer discretion advisedExplicit chemistry

The Dub Tub

Corals, Lies & Reagents

One Red Sea Reefer Max 350 G2+, about 52 gallons of saltwater, a test kit that never lies (the guy holding it sometimes does), and fifteen months of learning that in this hobby, stability beats size every time.

Aug 2025Tank got wet. Optimism peaked early, like most things.
~52 galActual water, once the rock admitted it had been exaggerating its size.
0.80 → 0.13Phosphate, ppm. Going down slowly, as one should.
4Casualties. The memorial wall is further down.

The saga so far

Every mistake, in order

Most reef sites show you the finished tank and the shopping list. This one shows the messy middle, where the numbers go sideways, the fish start beef, and you end up having long conversations with snails.

01Jul 2025
The honeymoon

Bought the tank. Bought "live" rock. Felt like a scientist.

A Red Sea Reefer Max 350 G2+ and 65 pounds of rock from the local fish store, sold as live. It was painted. That gorgeous purple wasn't coralline algae, it was paint, and the fish have been licking it off ever since. Catfished by a rock on day one.

The cycle stalled on alkalinity and pH, which is the tank's way of saying "maybe read the instructions first."

Lesson: if it's purple, cheap and too good to be true, it's paint. Applies to more than rock.

02Jul 2025
The sand saga

"Rinse your aragonite until the water runs clear," they said.

So I did. I ran hundreds of gallons of water through it for hours and hours and hours. Then I spread it out to dry for almost two weeks in the free-use foundry we call Arizona. By the end, my fingertips were sanded raw. The water never ran clear, by the way. It never does, and nobody on YouTube mentions that part.

I now have a personal relationship with every single grain of that sand. We're on a first-name basis. A few of them have turned a little green lately, and honestly, I take it personally.

Lesson: aragonite doesn't run clear. It runs your whole weekend.

03Late 2025
The one thing I did right

Foreplay matters. I seeded the pods months before anyone moved in.

Once the cycle finally finished, four packs of live copepods went in, and then I waited. For months. The idea was to let the pod population get established and keep itself going in the rock and the sump before anything showed up to eat it.

The three Banggai cardinals went in first, about two months after the cycle. The watchman goby and the pistol shrimp came about a month later. The green mandarin came a month after that, once I was sure the pods could keep up. Mandarins eat almost nothing but pods, and a lot of them starve in new tanks because nobody waited.

Lesson: patience pays off, in the tank and everywhere else. The mandarin is fat and happy to this day.

04Late 2025 – early 2026
The first funerals

A Duncan grew three new heads, then lost the will to live. Relatable.

Tissue pulled back from the base up over a couple of months. The acan that followed was gone in about two weeks. The Duncan went in undipped; the acan got dipped first, and the Duncan got pulled and dipped with it after the fact, which is like using protection after the deed is done.

Lesson: no coral until the water is boring for a long, long time. In a reef tank, boring is sexy.

05Summer 2026
The advice

Some very confident internet advice: "just put more in."

Nitrate was bottomed out, so the plan was more coral food, a lot more fish food, and frozen mysis tossed in juice and all. Nitrate came up. So did phosphate, to about eight times where corals want it. Turns out "just put more in" is bad advice in most areas of life.

Bonus round: the test kit had been reporting phosphorus (P), not phosphate (PO4), the entire time. Those differ by a factor of 3.067. Every decision before that discovery was made with a third of the truth, which is also how most of my twenties went.

Lesson: check the units before you check your feelings.

06Aug – Oct 2026
The phosphate wars

Resin, regeneration, more resin, and a lot of dripping.

Phosphate resin went in. Then the regeneration ritual: an IV drip of bottles and airline tubing, eight to ten hours per batch, with all the romance of a colonoscopy prep. Phosphate sat at 0.60 and refused to budge.

Meanwhile alkalinity climbed to 12.9 with zero corals using any of it. The working theory: gunk rotting in the sand was slowly dissolving the rock, feeding it back into the water. The fix was weekly 26 gallon water changes with a lower-alkalinity salt, with magnesium corrected in the bucket before it went in.

Lesson: the rock and sand hold a grudge. You can't dilute your way out of a relationship that toxic.

07Oct – Nov 2026
The turnaround

A liquid phosphate remover, a real pipette, and a strainer.

A small daily dose of liquid phosphate remover, dripped in slowly over a couple of hours, finally got things moving: 0.57, 0.40, 0.28, then the low 0.20s. Alkalinity came back into range for the first time in months.

Then the cheap trick that beat everything expensive: thawing frozen mysis in a homemade mesh-bottom cup so the phosphate-heavy juice drains away instead of going in the tank. Phosphate dropped four days straight during a week of feeding more, not less. Pull out before you put in. Words to live by.

Then, during the first water change on the new salt: real coralline algae spreading on the rock and the front glass. Actual living purple, not paint. Turns out it's always better when it's natural.

Lesson: the cheapest fix was a strainer. Of course it was.

08Ongoing
The bully problem

One six-line wrasse, one oversized cardinal, zero manners.

The six-line chases the gobies through a rock arch with far too many tunnels, so nobody can catch it. One night it swam into the hospital box through the feeding holes in the lid. I had him. I hesitated. He left. I think about it more than I think about my exes.

He's been in and out of every hole in that rockwork. Let's just say he gets around. The bigger Banggai cardinal already killed its tankmate. Both are getting evicted the moment the bait trap does its job.

Lesson: "peaceful community fish" is a dating-profile description, not a promise.

09Now
Where it stands

Solar powered, on a new salt, and slightly low on everything for once.

The tank runs on solar during the day with a battery backup, and it has already ridden out real power outages. The new salt went in on November 19. Alkalinity and calcium are drifting a little low now, which after two months of everything running high feels like a vacation.

Lesson: there is no "done." Only "done for this week."

Live from the tub

Today's numbers

Tested at home on a Hanna Marine Master photometer, with pipettes checked against a scale. Green is in range, yellow is close, red needs attention. Corals don't go back in until everything is boring.

The testing station on a kitchen counter: Hanna Marine Master photometer, open reagent case, three pipettes on a stand, racks of color-coded tips and a refractometer
The panel test setup. Yes, the kitchen counter is a lab now. No, it's not up for discussion.

Phosphate (ppm PO4) since May

That mountain in the middle is what "just put more in" looks like. The slide down the right side is a strainer.

Alkalinity (dKH) since March

There wasn't a single coral in the tank, and alkalinity still hit 12.9. The rock was dissolving itself out of spite.

Corals, Lies & Reagents

Lies I was told (some by myself)

Lie #1

"Phosphate 0.23"

That was phosphorus (P), not phosphate (PO4). Multiply P by 3.067 to get PO4. Know what your kit is actually reporting before you act on it.

Lie #2

"Calcium 548"

A 0.1 mL sample eyeballed with a syringe is a guessing game. A proper 100 µL pipette brought the same water back to about 400. Precision matters. Ask anyone.

Lie #3

"The salt is the salt"

Batches of the same brand came in well under the label on magnesium. Test every batch before it goes in, and fix it in the bucket.

Lie #4

"A water change fixes it"

Swapping half the water barely moved phosphate. When the rock and sand are leaking, you need something actively pulling it out.

Lie #5

"Rinsed mysis is clean"

Soaking and pouring off still leaves the phosphate juice and fines at the bottom. Drain it through mesh. Every time. No exceptions.

Lie #6

"Just one more change won't hurt"

Change one thing, test for a few days, write it down. Three changes at once teaches you nothing, and I've proven that more than once.

Reef in Peace

The memorial wall

Every reefer has one. Most just don't post it. These paid tuition for the rest of us.

R · I · P

The Duncan

Duncan coral · 2025

Grew three brand new heads, then decided this water wasn't worth it. Can't say I blame him.

Cause: beginner chemistry

R · I · P

The Acan

Acan coral, 5 heads · early 2026

Five heads, and somehow none of them were thinking clearly. Gone in about two weeks.

Cause: see above

R · I · P

The Dragonet

Ruby red dragonet · 1 week

Found buried head-first in the sand. The six-line wrasse is the prime suspect, and has lawyered up.

Cause: tank bully (alleged)

R · I · P

The Cardinal

Banggai cardinal · 2026

Beaten up by its larger roommate and never recovered. The roommate is being evicted, no deposit back.

Cause: roommate

The goods

What's in the tub (and what got kicked out)

Everything here is in use right now, unless the card says it's retired or waiting on the shelf for corals. Every card says what it actually did in this tank, good or bad.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some other links on this site may also be affiliate links. If you buy through one, The Dub Tub may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Recommendations are based on what's actually been used in this tank.

Follow the chaos

Come for the corals. Stay for the drama.

Weekly test results, water change days, and the ongoing attempt to trap a six-line wrasse that is clearly smarter than its owner.

Instagram · @TheDubTub77TikTok · soonYouTube · soon