Bought the tank. Bought "live" rock. Felt like a scientist.
A Red Sea Reefer Max 350 G2+ and 65 pounds of rock from the local fish store, sold as live. It was painted. That gorgeous purple wasn't coralline algae, it was paint, and the fish have been licking it off ever since. Catfished by a rock on day one.
The cycle stalled on alkalinity and pH, which is the tank's way of saying "maybe read the instructions first."
Lesson: if it's purple, cheap and too good to be true, it's paint. Applies to more than rock.